this is to follow up my last post, and responses (keep in mind this is difficult to cut down to something to write in a blog)
Let me ask you this:
Can you in and of yourself mustar up enough faith to save youself?--No you cannot!
The point here in James 2 is that "Faith" is given by God, (Rom 1:17a--"from faith to faith")--It is Christ's faith given to us which saves us. Therefore since faith is from Christ it is Christ who WILL produce fruit (seen by deeds) in our lives. One thing I told the quizzers is that this does NOT mean we will all steadily grow into mature saints instantly. (Don, so I am NOT condemning or questioning your friends salvation) But the fact is, if Christ IS in you, there WILL be change...there must be. (at some level, at some rate---Don you have said you've seen fruit in your friend...though not 'deeds' necessarally....like i said not all will grow and mature at the same rate..that doesn't mean grace is yanked away from them)
This is not saying Christians won't struggle and/or even fail. this is NOT saying faith is NOT enough! It is saying that Faith (a faith given by Christ) WILL produce fruit, at some level. Of course we are saved by FAITH...by GRACE....Works do not save us...But Grace and Faith WILL produce those works, or else it's not faith from Christ. So the emphasis is the FAITH, and it's the FAITH that saves...but that faith will produce Fruit...
I agree with you, this is complex and at times it seems the Bible contradicts itself, but that is because God is Bigger, and more Complex than our simple logic. Just as the Bible says that God chooses those whom He saves, yet it also says whoever believes will be saved. Is one right and the other wrong? NO!! The are both true...HOW you ask....I can't explain....But I also can't explain a God as big and Mighty as my God. Don't excuse something too quickly just because it doesn't stand up to human logic...I stand by what I wrote...Read it again, you might find I'm saying about the same as you, just in different terms.
Lastly...a thought I just had about all this......Answer this question: WHY ARE WE SAVED? my answer would be to Glorify God. Isn't that what it is all about...that God may be Glorified through us?....If this is so, and it's Christ in us who saves us (the hope of glory Col 1:27) than will he not work in and through us so that He will be evident to others through us? hence why I said James (chapter 2 included) is a book about
the fruit of grace.----it's all about God's grace...It's all about His glory...these deeds are produced in us..not to prove to God we are saved...but so that God may be glorified through us. makes sense to me....maybe not to you though...then I agree to disagree....Blessings, and to God be the Glory